Closing the gap between the science and politics of progress
…a powerful, timely and very insightful paper
I think it’s a great paper, well done. I really enjoyed it and have passed it on to several people. I love Obama’s quote (and your analysis of it).
Is the West really the best?
… this is a wonderful (academic) essay by Australian Social Scientist Richard Eckersley, about the limitations of the development indicators used to measure progress. So much in it. So thought provoking.
Thanks again for your paper, which I have now read. It raises many very interesting points, which I will ponder and try to discuss with a few of my colleagues here….Intuitively, I very much agree with you (and am therefore pondering “now what”).
This article poses and comprehensively addresses questions that I regard as being of utmost importance to the development field.
The paper tackles an important topic. As the author says, the measures we use to track human progress and development matter. By questioning assumptions about common measures used and by emphasizing gaps in these measures related to psychosocial aspects of well-being, the paper has the potential to make a contribution to discourse and policy on global measures of progress.
….I am in Sweden now giving a talk on cultural differences of self and values between Gabon and more capitalistic cultures and how this relates to addiction. I find your work on cultural fraud and addiction fascinating.
I am a high school World Cultures teacher in SW Missouri (US). I am currently prepping my students to look at the world as geographers would as we prepare to explore the different cultures of the world. I will be starting a small unit on world religions very soon. I plan on having my students read your article, “Culture, spirituality, religion and health: looking at the big picture”. I want the students to understand the importance of religion on the cultural makeup of the region we are studying, but also its impact on society. Your article will lead to a thought provoking exercise for them. I was trying to find a bias in your writing, but I couldn’t pinpoint one (well done). I want my students’ to try to find one as well….Thanks for your work to better our world, especially your focus on the young ones!
…congratulations for your great work on alternative indicators of progress…When I found SWB, I considered it as a real alternative to GDP for meassuring the “development” of societies. But then, I got to a similar conclussion as you: that it has an individualistic bias and it does not emphasize enough intrinsic values such as trascendence, meaning and flourishing.
I am finishing an instructionally oriented book that fuses mindfulness and kindness. The last chapter shifts the perspective from the personal to societal. I’ve conducted an extensive literature review and just found “Is modern Western culture a health hazard?” to be a powerful and clear analysis that is exactly what I need!
I am…researching into the link between popularised behavioral and belief patterns in modern Western cultures and their link to psychological well-being in young people. I have read a large volume of your work, and have been highly inspired by your research. In particular your book Well and Good, and your article Is Western Culture a Health Hazard? have been very influential in helping me frame my research.
I have worked with young people for almost 20 years and completed and was awarded my PhD this year related to examining anger and aggression with rural adolescent males. I am constantly challenged by your articles and am grateful as they continue to broaden my thinking. Your work has influenced me greatly.
.….I have attached a letter explaining why your work has suddenly become so important to a bunch of seventeen and eighteen year olds in southern Sydney.…I am teaching a Year 12 Society and Culture class at Gymea TAFE in Sydney’s south. High school has not worked out for my students and they are having another go at completing Year 12 at TAFE. The students must choose a research topic for the NSW HSC. To my surprise many have chosen topics related to happiness and youth. They are concerned that they and so many of their peers have mental illness. Others have chosen topics related to consumerism, wealth and misplaced priorities. Others have chosen to research tribal societies, their values and way of life as they feel strongly something important is missing in our modern life. As you can see discovering your books and internet material has been a big deal.
I’ve just finished reading Well & Good. Congratulations on an outstanding piece of work. You have so many insightful comments that I felt this is a book many others should read. Unfortunately, my guess is that those who would benefit the most are the ones who, preoccupied with everything that seems urgent, would never sit down to read it.
On topics you cover that I’m familiar with, such as happiness research and problems with economic growth, I felt you covered key points with elegance and sensitivity. On topics I know much less about, such as youth matters, I felt in the hands of a master.
Your work is a source of great inspiration and insight and I wish to thank you personally for making your wealth of research readily available. You write with such clarity and passion.
I have recently drafted a Youth Strategy for [a Sydney] Council… and initially struggled to understand the research findings. In particular I was baffled that our youth survey of more than 1,000 young people aged 12 to 24 showed that despite generally ‘being happy with their lives on a whole’, fit and in good general health, the vast majority (for young adults 75%) said that they experienced symptoms of anxiety, stress and depression on a regular basis.
Your article “A new narrative of young people’s health and wellbeing” was a turning point for me in making sense of these findings and become a pivot point in the analysis of the data. I soon became engrossed in your work – especially your book “Well & Good: Morality, meaning and happiness” which also struck a personal chord. As an immigrant myself, and having travelled extensively in “developing countries”, I completely relate to the culture shock you describe on coming back to the so-called developed world.
For me, your work has transformed the muddle of issues and complexities that characterise modern western living into something comprehensible and hence more manageable. I have taken the liberty of quoting you extensively in the draft Youth Strategy and hope that you will find that I have been faithful to your work.
Thank you for sharing your studies for free. I am a masters student, particularly interested in youth mental health. We need more wisdom and genuine social service in our society, and its been a pleasure for me to find it here on your site.
Thank you very much for your inspirational writing. Currently, I am a student at Florida State College of Jacksonville in Jacksonville, FL. Your article “The West’s Deepening Cultural Crisis” really provides some insight of our current cultural problems. My assignment/essay for English 1102 required me to find sources for my paper through the database and your article appeared with my search and has really helped provide insight for my paper and myself personally, and I would like to thank you very much!
I came across your work the first time after reading a paper ‘Is Western Culture a Health Hazard?’ that became required reading for all classes I have been teaching since then. You are one of the few authors I have read capable of putting together different and apparently distant subjects such as mental wellbeing, culture, health, economics and aspirations in life and the environment. A truly unique perspective I totally appreciate. In public health, it is so difficult to find big-picture and free intellectuals, given the funding rat race that shapes behaviours and aspirations…so your perspective is fresh and highly respected.
A new narrative of young people’s health and wellbeing, 2011
Just finished your paper – it’s terrific! A really well reasoned case (of course: the Eckersley hallmark!) and a beautiful distillation of a huge and complex topic.
The science and politics of population health, 2011
This thoughtful and insightful article draws on a diverse range of theoretical and policy literatures to present a compelling case for a broader framing and understanding of the scope of population health concerns and drivers. … A particular strength of the article is the author’s commitment to draw out and explore the implications of these reflections for the challenges and issues facing young people – as well as for the important work underway in many settings to develop and implement new and broader measures of wellbeing and ‘progress’. …This is a wide ranging and valuable contribution to the rapidly growing literature exploring the policy implications of an alternative political paradigm based on social and ecological wellbeing and sustainability. The article raises a host of challenging and complex questions which merit further consideration and debate.
I have only favourable comments to make on this valuable paper, the publication of which I entirely endorse. Eckersley’s arguments about the need for population health approaches to be re-thought are cogently argued. He effectively challenges some of the dominant orthodoxies which actually hinder broader understandings of what creates and damages health and wellbeing, so this article needs to reach the public health community. He convincingly explains the relevance of mental health and illness to population health and the problems with current (socio-economic) conceptualisations of the social determinants of health. His explanation of how and why epidemiology currently fails to grasp the importance of ‘culture’ is particularly timely. Few in public health truly understand the distinction between social structure and culture, so the influence of the latter tends to be profoundly under-estimated. Importantly for an international readership, he explains the relevance of the contemporary ‘dis-eases’ of affluent Western societies to the developing world. He is to be congratulated, I believe, on this important and well-written paper.
Well & Good
Thought-provoking and insightful, this book synthesizes recent research and presents a range of perspectives on key social issues…
A profoundly pessimistic book concerning the lack of meaning in modern Western life.
Handles the complex material beautifully…always clear, succinct and often personal.
Affirms strongly the power of the human spirit to divert the cultural currents of history.
Lucid and thought-provoking…has done an admirable job of addressing issues of importance to our emotional survival in a culture that often values things over people.
One of the key strengths of this book is his ability to synthesise knowledge from myriad disciplines and arrive at a coherent story…very readable and accessible to a wide audience….I strongly recommend the book as general reading for anyone interested in the future of our society and as specific reading on a variety of public health courses where the teacher wants to encourage students to think beyond the square….
Well and good…is an insightful interpretation of the cultural situation that conditions the thinking and feelings of young people – and not only the young. We consider this book (and much of Eckersley’s other writings) essential reading for educators.
Richard Eckersley’s inspiring book, Well & Good – Morality, meaning and happiness, reminds me why I remain, after twenty years (since Casualties of Change appeared in 1988) such an avid admirer of his work and writings. Here again, Richard highlights the ambiguities and dangers inherent in our flawed post-modern Western society, especially in relation to young people. With courage and humility, he examines what we all really want and need as human beings in order to be whole and fully functional individuals… I recommend Well & Good to anybody seeking a better understanding of the critical importance of culture and environment to health and wellbeing.
Compellingly written, accessible and with your usual incisive abilities to get at the heart of so much ambiguous, complex, emotionally difficult and urgently important subject matter.
I have just finished reading your wise and inspiring book, Well & Good. It not only provides an alternative world outlook to the dominant economic model but also a corrective to the psychologists who are only concerned with personal development and subjective wellbeing.
I wanted to compliment you on Well and Good… I think it’s an amazing achievement, positively glowing with insight, ideas and comment. I love the way you don’t shy from the ‘big questions’, even as you stay so attuned to the ‘micro’ as well. And it’s all done with an accessibility and lightness of touch which belies the depth of the issues you raise.
‘Well & Good’ – what an unremittingly grim, bleak, gloom-and-doom book this is! Well written, but oh, dearie me, what a sad view you paint of human existence, past, present and (especially) future.
…your book is by far the best book I have ever read on the deeper reasons why the world is in such a mess. There is no one else writing what you are writing. There is a huge market for what you write about, because a lot of people sense a deep spiritual malaise in the modern world.
I cannot over-state how influential, inspiring and original I thought ‘Well and Good’ was. You may find this bizarre – but this is what happens with books and ideas – but your influence on us – and us framing the idea of ‘the official future’ along the lines you described – has led to a small national debate in Scotland about the best way forward for the country.
I have been studying your book very closely, and I am really learning heaps from it. I like your calm, balanced style, balancing one argument against another, and then placing your own weight on one side.
I recently finished Well & Good, which I think is one of the best and most profound books I have read.
This is really terrific. I don’t quite know how you’ve done this, but the marriage of non-obvious theory with social issues is exceptionally engaging.
Of all the people whose work I read I think I am closer to your position than anyone else’s. As a Centre we’ve increasingly moved in your direction and think that we need to focus on alerting people to issues of materialism and individualism.
…I would not have got into this area without your work….we got from the Scottish Government came from a short application which was in large measure based on your analysis. I love the way you write and have learned so much from your work.
The paper by Eckersley in this issue of IJE is important in several respects. It represents a rare attempt to deal with a complex subject that has traditionally stood outside what Thomas Kuhn would call “normal science” in epidemiology. It surveys a vast body of evidence, concluding, in response to the question posed by the title, that yes, modern Western culture is a health hazard….. Eckersley’s paper is likely to stimulate discussion and controversy. Any discussion of culture is strikingly unorthodox and hampered by weak evidence. It is especially significant that culture has …been largely ignored or denuded of its essential meaning in contemporary discourse surrounding determinants of population health.
I find much in Eckersley’s provocative paper to agree with. I also appreciate his efforts to incorporate cultural explanations into social epidemiology. In so doing he has given the field a needed theoretical push to move beyond a narrow focus on social and economic relationships to consideration of systems of meaning in the causation of disease. Yet, like many anthropologists these days, I experience considerable intellectual anxiety over the general and uncritical use of culture as an explanatory variable.
Richard Eckersley deserves credit for discussing ‘culture’ seriously as a determinant of health. As he points out, culture is so encompassing, and hence taken for granted, that unless we observe something foreign to our own socialization, it is easy to forget that culture is even there… Unfortunately, however, Eckersley’s theoretical orientation is problematic in several ways, thus undermining his aim.
I read your recent essay in Global Change and Human Health, and wanted to tell you how much I gained from it. I really appreciate your good insights, and the fine and human way that you have presented them.
…we think that you, better than anyone, have understood/captured the bigger picture of the world which today’s young people inhabit.
I continue to learn from your work, and it is a pleasure to share it with our pre- and post-doctoral adolescent health fellows…Your fusion of public health, social determinants, economic and cultural insights provides a rich and challenging frame – – to explore, to galvanize, to act.
Very, very interesting.… These are very important ideas.
I’ve enjoyed reading both your papers and e-mails; they have often helped me gain a new perspective on modern mental health (or lack thereof!)
I’m continually impressed and inspired by your work.
Thanks for the article . . . I think it’s a brilliant piece of work–perhaps because it so well articulates ideas I’ve been mulling over of late. I’ve passed it along to a number of my academic & professional contacts here in Canada (hope you don’t mind).
What a terrific piece this is. I really appreciate the way you codify and analyze the different responses. This is immensely useful to me …your piece really struck a nerve — It’s right on point in articulating notions that have been flitting around more vaguely in the back of my head….Just a terrific piece of insight.
It was very good to have you pushing us conceptually. It is an immensely valuable perspective that you bring.
The depth of your interest and concern over the years about the plight of young people shines through, and gives perspectives that others couldn’t provide. I think it is beautifully written and thought-provoking, challenging us all to consider the society we have created and the impact of it on our young people.
Your work consistently asks the most important questions and finds very helpful and indicative answers. I have always held firmly onto your work on happiness and gained confidence from it to urge parents to change their priorities.
I happened to read your article “Don’t panic-it’s only the apocalypse” published in the Sydney Morning Herald earlier this month. I cut the article out and have re-read it several times since. I wanted to write to you and thank you for articulating many things I feel about the state of our unsteady world, and most importantly the ways we can approach it and change it for the better….Thank you again for what I found to be a deeply motivating article.
I have been reading quite a few of your journal and newspaper articles and would like to say that I am with you all the way. You have added much to the quality of essays I am currently doing and I will be referring to your work in my dissertation.
…your writing is so interesting and cutting-edge. I hope you continue the good work.
I’m currently reading one of your papers ‘Cultural Fraud’: The Role of Culture In Drug Abuse. I must say I find your perspective extremely insightful and refreshing, particularly as a young person who has some first-hand knowledge of the types of issues you talk about in this piece. So far in fact, I’m finding that yours is about the most up-to-date and accurate work dealing with the issue of modern Western culture and its relationship to health.
..my thesis …finds strong support to your arguments that Western culture’s emphasis on individualism and materialism has a detrimental effect on individuals’ well-being, contributing to drug (ab)use and other psychosocial problems among adolescents and young adults. In my thesis there are extensive references related to your work as you are one of the very few researchers who have emphasised the detrimental effects of individualism on drug (ab)use.